Re: University researchers

Eliza Lindsay (eliza@q7.com)
Sat, 22 Aug 1998 03:06:01 -0700 (PDT)

Wow, lots of flames....No, really as i write the house two doors down
(100+ feet away) is smouldering. It went up in flames about 2 hours ago
and is really quite scary to think about. No one seems to have been hurt
but all of us have just breathed in a lot of...well you know...and as we
speak a lot of you know is settling over all our yards and my backyard
happens to be my major vegetable food source....Course, every day things
fall down upon it the like of which should never have been...Don't mind me
I'm tired after a day of harvesting flowers at my flower garden/field
which is about 12 miles from here...and I need to get up at 5:30 but cna't
sleep now...

But, really on topic. I don't think university researchers as a lot are
corrupt. I do think that the really/truly important biases are present
throughout society; university researchers, mostly, no more nor less
affected by those biases. There isn't, imho, such a think as biasless
research/thought/life. The questions to ask is what biases are influencing
your research and do you want those to be the biases that influence your
research.

A lot of bias creeps in at the level of what questions are
framed for research/what's considered worthy of research. I always think
it is a good idea to ask the question: Why are these the questions we're
asking? Why is this area something we want to study? (For example, ask:
Why has there been so much focus on the "hereditary" causes of cancer?
Or, in a particular case: Why are we searching for the "hereditary"
causes of *this* cancer? The answer(s), the myriad ones that are possible,
tell much. When I ask these questions they lead me to reflect on the
possibilty of environmental causes to cancer and the reasons these causes
may be neglected more than they deserve...They lead me to think of
thousands of worthwhile questions for study. Excuse me, I'm not
particularly coherent right now because I am very tired but I can't sleep
too much fire truck noise...and can't leave easily because streets blocked
off...)

OTOH, I think where one gets one's funding will curtail one's creativity
in developing questions for research. And, there's no doubt about where
university ag and science departments get the bulk of their
funding...Again, this isn't to suggest that we're talking about "bad
science" or "corruption" just the everday nature of how bias works....

Of course, you might say, my thoughts reflect my own biases and academic
background in the philosophy of science (social science).

:-)
eliza

To Unsubscribe: Email majordomo@ces.ncsu.edu with "unsubscribe sanet-mg".
To Subscribe to Digest: Email majordomo@ces.ncsu.edu with the command
"subscribe sanet-mg-digest".