Re: Is sustained-yield sustainable?

Radhika Bala (rbala@ncatfyv.uark.edu)
Fri, 15 Mar 1996 14:47:39 -0600 (CST)


> 2. The US does not provide 85% of the world's relief, if I am using
> the term correctly. We did an analysis of food movement (in $)
> between DMEC (developed market economy countries) and LDC (less
> developed countries) using UN and FAO figures for 1990. It was
> interesting to note that 75% of the dollar value of food exported by
> DMECES was imported by other DMECS, and further, that 67% of the
> dollar value of food exported by the LDC's was imported by the DMECS.
> So, in terms of commerce, the "high yield" orientation of our
> agricultural systems is highly effective at feeding the 16% of the
> world's population that lives in the DMECS - period. Doesn't seem to
> be doing much for the rest of the world. This "feeding the world"
> argument is crap. Ann

> Dr. E. Ann Clark

Ann, I've always enjoyed your thoughtful and reasoned responses
to this group. Your observation here reminded me of a brief
passage in V.S. Naipaul's book "India: A Million Mutinies Now"
that I read several years ago but which remains in my mind.

Debu, a middle-class Indian reminisces about his participation in
the Marxist movement in West Bengal and his eventual ideological
fallout with the party leadership. His decision to join a radical
communist party comes at a time when India is in the midst of a
food crisis. There were food riots and people were being shot by
the police. People, says Debu, were eating "milo", a coarse type
of sorghum:

"...which the Americans fed their pigs, and which they had sent
over as charity, and the Government of India...used to feed the
village poor. I was very ashamed and angry. To me it wasn't the
poor who were eating it. It was Indians and Bengalis."

I do not mean this to take on the tone of a B-grade Greenpeace
bulletin, but statistics on the inequities of land use and resource
consumption suddenly become staggeringly real when the one with the
begging bowl has a real human face, one that looks startlingly like
yours.

-- 
Radhika B.
rbala@ncatfyv.uark.edu